How to Prevent Hiring Managers from Pigeon-Holing You As An Educator

Are you ready for some controversial advice?

You may not want to hear this, but I believe it’s true with all my heart.

I also believe it’s how I found career success in three different industries with nothing but a Master’s in Teaching and three years teaching experience.

Tired of hiring managers pigeonholing you as an "educator"? Here's how to prevent it!

Hiring Managers Often Use Stereotypes

I don’t mean this as a slight to hiring managers. It’s simply how the business works. When you’ve come across 2,500 resumes and hired 250+ people per year, for right or wrong, you tend to get a sense of people based on the items listed on their resume.

And if you show up with a traditional teacher resume, with all the bullet points they’ve seen from teachers year after year?

You’ll get stuck in the “No, thank you” pile without a second glance.

Use Those Stereotypes to Your Advantage

The thing few people consider, though, is that you can use stereotypes to your advantage.

There are many stereotypes in education, and if you taught for more than a year you probably came across several of them. (And if you are one of them, I apologize if I offend you ;-)).

The trick is to identify the stereotype your resume puts you in and edit it to put you in a better one.

Let’s start with a few GOOD teacher stereotypes. These are stereotypes you want to rewrite your resume to convey, and how you want to present yourself in interviews.

  • The Technology Wizard – Everyone thinks you use tons of technology in the classroom, even if it’s just putting homework assignments on a classroom blog. You’ve “taken advantage” of all the mandatory professional development technology courses and have students use the Internet for a number of classroom projects. If you graduated from an education program in the past five years, you can probably pull this stereotype off.
  • The “All About My Subject Area” Nerd – You love, love, love your field. All of your hobbies, activities, and extracurricular involve your subject area. And while you were a good classroom manager and cared about your kids, more often than not you looked forward to presenting on a given topic. You’re aiming for a job that let’s you use your specialized knowledge on a daily basis, or at least t0
  • The “Networking and Communication” Professional – Your favorite part of teaching was meeting everyone on the first day of school and attending PTA and educator meetings. You’re a member of tons of community organizations (Rotary, Alumni, Community, etc) and you know how to talk to and motivate people.

Here are a few BAD teacher stereotypes:

  • The “Stuck in My Ways” Old Person – You aren’t all that interested in feedback, and even when no one is excited to try your way you’re still confident it’s the best way to do it. Your students sometimes respect you, but more often than not they “check out” and get away with it because they pretend to be respectful. You may not actually be “old” — but these behaviors certainly make you seem that way.
  • The Angry Guy – Everybody’s doing everything wrong and you know the right way to do it. You’re leaving teaching because “No one’s doing it right,” and “You need more respect for your job.” You may actually need more respect, but saying so is a surefire way to appear immature.
  • The Gentle Gal – You became a teacher because you are passionate about education and the students – only to burn out within a few years. You’re looking for something – anything—that could help you relax and get a new start. (Again… this may be true, but NO ONE wants to hire someone just to give them a fresh start!)

You might be able to see by now that this is all a matter of perception.

GOOD teacher stereotypes tag you with valuable skills that someone might want to hire (technology, expertise, people skills).

BAD teacher stereotypes mark you as someone with poor workplace habits (need for authority, bad attitude, still wishes she were a teacher).

Tired of hiring managers pigeonholing you as an "educator"? Here's how to prevent it!

Build Your Resume Towards a Good Stereotype

Take a look at your resume. Is there anything on there about real skills you can bring to an organization? Or did you just kind of describe what you did as a teacher?

While what you did as a teacher is very important, it’s not what a recruiter wants to read.

Help them see through all the details to the core skills you offer: being a well-rounded professional with team-work experience; being a specialist with practical experience in a given topic; being a fledgling manager with experience with leading and inspiring a variety of audiences.

The purpose of your resume is to tie a bridge from your old job to a new job. Every sentence on your resume should be “about” your work as a teacher, but make a case for a skill that’s in the job description of the job to which you’re applying.

Here’s a quick example of bullet points that might appear on a resume for a Project Management job (and there are more examples in the eBook):

Teaching Resume Bullet Points:

  • Monitor classroom behavior and call home for disruptive students.
  • Monitor and record attendance throughout the year.
  • Design and teach a variety of topics.

All of these bullet points are well-written and accurate. But they don’t draw a link between teaching and Project Management as clearly as they could.

Here’s how I would rewrite that section to present yourself as a “Networking and Communication” Professional using keywords or ideas from a Project Management job description:

Project Management Resume Bullet Points:

  • Engage in relationship-building exercises, monitor progress, and meet with key stakeholders about student performance
  • Track and analyze key metrics and present findings each year.
  • Research, organize, and implement daily presentations on a variety of topics with a 84% information retention rate [AKA average test scores].

It will take a little time, and it will be a little hard. But the result will make it easier for the recruiting professional to say “YES”!

In what way are you feeling pigeon-holed? Do you never get the interview, or do you never get the job after the interview? Let me know in the comments and I’ll help you out!

Scroll to Top